NY Inspectors Find Local Inspection Services

Best Well Pump Replacement in Ithaca, NY

Compare 15 local well pump replacement providers in Ithaca. Verified listings with real contact info.

15 verified providers · Updated 2026-04-19

Quick Compare

1

Steamback Renewable Thermal

5.0 ★ (1 reviews)

Call
2

Roto-Rooter of Ithaca and Cortland

5.0 ★ (138 reviews)

Call
3

Donohue-Halverson Plumbing, Heating & Cooling

4.8 ★ (367 reviews)

Call
1

Steamback Renewable Thermal

5.0 (1 reviews)
432 N Tioga St, Ithaca, NY 14850
Mon–Fri 9am–3pm · Sat–Sun Closed
2

Roto-Rooter of Ithaca and Cortland

5.0 (138 reviews)
175 Woolf Ln, Ithaca, NY 14850
Open 24 Hours
3

Donohue-Halverson Plumbing, Heating & Cooling

4.8 (367 reviews)
71 Bishop Rd, Newfield, NY 14867
Open 24 Hours
4

Jay Payton Well Drilling

5.0 (11 reviews)
34 Pheasant Walk, Ithaca, NY 14850
5

Lowes Soft Water Service Inc

4.4 (7 reviews)
12 Elm St, Trumansburg, NY 14886
Mon–Fri 8am–4pm · Sat 8am–12pm · Sun Closed
6

Berry Drilling

5.0 (1 reviews)
7156 Curry Rd, Trumansburg, NY 14886
7

Randolph Well & Pump Co. Inc.

4.9 (37 reviews)
41 Gulf Hill Rd, McLean, NY 13102
Mon–Fri 24hrs · Sat–Sun Closed
8

Utter Well Drilling

4.6 (19 reviews)
8681 Lodi Center Rd, Lodi, NY 14860
9

Hughson Well Drilling and pump repair

4.9 (48 reviews)
293 Jackson Creek Rd, Erin, NY 14838
10

Upstate Septic Pumping

5.0 (30 reviews)
1228 N Ketchumville Rd, Berkshire, NY 13736
Open 24 Hours
11

Charles A Talcott Well Drilling

4.3 (20 reviews)
799 NY-38, Owego, NY 13827
13

Wilcox Well Drilling

5.0 (5 reviews)
1158 Pleasant St, Horseheads, NY 14845
Open 24 Hours
14

Sheesley's Sewer Service Inc

4.6 (264 reviews)
1862 Grand Central Ave, Elmira Heights, NY 14903
Open 24 Hours
15

W H Vanderhoof Well Drilling

4.4 (8 reviews)
48 Camptown Rd, Waverly, NY 14892

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to replace a well pump in New York?

Well pump replacement typically costs $1,500 to $4,500, depending on well depth, pump size, and accessibility. Deeper wells in bedrock areas cost more due to additional pipe and wire. This includes the pump, drop pipe, wiring, and labor.

How do I know if my well pump needs replacement?

Signs include frequent cycling (turning on and off), loss of water pressure, no water at all, the pump running continuously without shutting off, unusually high electric bills, or dirty and sandy water. If your pump is over 10 years old and failing, replacement is usually better than repair.

How long does well pump replacement take in New York?

Most well pump replacements can be completed in 4-8 hours, depending on well depth and conditions. Emergency service may be available for same-day replacement in most areas, though emergency rates apply.

More Well Pump Replacement Nearby

Related Services in Ithaca

All services in Ithaca, NY →