NY Inspectors Find Local Inspection Services

Best Septic Tank Replacement in Ithaca, NY

Compare 12 local septic tank replacement providers in Ithaca. Verified listings with real contact info.

12 verified providers · Updated 2026-04-19

Quick Compare

1

Drain Brain

4.4 ★ (32 reviews)

Call
2

Roto-Rooter of Ithaca and Cortland

5.0 ★ (138 reviews)

Call
3

Mark Thomas Septic Services

4.5 ★ (17 reviews)

Call
1

Drain Brain

4.4 (32 reviews)
Ithaca, NY 14850, USA
2

Roto-Rooter of Ithaca and Cortland

5.0 (138 reviews)
175 Woolf Ln, Ithaca, NY 14850
Open 24 Hours
3

Mark Thomas Septic Services

4.5 (17 reviews)
90 Pleasant Hollow Rd, Freeville, NY 13068
Mon–Fri 7am–5pm · Sat–Sun Closed
4

Stinky's Tank Services

3.8 (24 reviews)
399 Main St, Freeville, NY 13068
Mon–Fri 8am–4pm · Sat–Sun Closed
5

Kirksway Farm Inc.

5.0 (18 reviews)
400 Auburn Rd, Lansing, NY 14882
Mon–Fri 8am–5pm · Sat 8am–12pm · Sun Closed
6

Palmer's Septic

5.0 (31 reviews)
4110 Cold Springs Rd, Trumansburg, NY 14886
Mon–Fri 7am–4pm · Sat 7am–12pm · Sun Closed
7

Johns Septic Pumping

5.0 (1 reviews)
8669 NY-89, Interlaken, NY 14847
8

Ted Mc Bride Jr Septic Services

4.1 (18 reviews)
1349 Fisher Ave, Cortland, NY 13045
Open 24 Hours
9

Upstate Septic Pumping

5.0 (30 reviews)
1228 N Ketchumville Rd, Berkshire, NY 13736
Open 24 Hours
10

Pendell Septic Services

4.6 (12 reviews)
Smith Hill Rd, Lisle, NY 13797
11

Falkowski Sewer Service & Excavating

4.8 (45 reviews)
305 Watkins Rd, Horseheads, NY 14845
Mon–Fri 8am–4pm · Sat–Sun Closed
12

Sheesley's Sewer Service Inc

4.6 (264 reviews)
1862 Grand Central Ave, Elmira Heights, NY 14903
Open 24 Hours

Frequently Asked Questions

When does a septic tank need to be replaced in New York?

A tank needs replacement when it has severe structural damage, extensive corrosion (common in older steel tanks), multiple large cracks, or when it is too small for current household usage. Concrete tanks can last 40+ years, while steel tanks often need replacement after 15-25 years.

How much does it cost to replace a septic tank in New York?

Septic tank replacement typically costs $5,000 to $10,000, including removal of the old tank, a new concrete or fiberglass tank, and reconnection to existing lines. Regional labor costs, permitting fees, and excavation requirements in developed areas affect pricing.

Can I upgrade to a larger tank during replacement in New York?

Yes, upgrading to a larger tank during replacement is common and often recommended. Your local board of health must approve the new tank size, and it must meet sizing requirements based on the number of bedrooms in your home.

More Septic Tank Replacement Nearby

Related Services in Ithaca

All services in Ithaca, NY →